Reader Report: Air France Premium Economy to Paris, Airbus A380

In June, I experienced Air France’s Premium Economy class from San Francisco (SFO) to Paris- Charles De Gaulle (CDG). I was heading to Athens and exploring Crete in Greece and wanted to see Berlin also.

During summer, Air France flies both an Airbus A380 and a B777 on the SFO-CDG route. United flies a Boeing 787 Dreamliner to Paris from SFO.

When pricing out various European carriers in which I could accrue miles on Alaska Airlines, I narrowed my choices to British Airways (through London), KLM (through Amsterdam), and Air France (through Paris) – all of which are Alaska Airlines Mileage Plan partners. I also included Virgin Atlantic, knowing I could earn points on Virgin America, which then would eventually transfer over into Alaska Airlines Mileage Plan program. KLM did not offer a premium economy product and between British Airways, Virgin Atlantic and Air France, Air France had the best airfare for Premium Economy.

On Air France, a round trip economy airfare was approximately $1,250 between SFO and CDG and its Premium Economy was just $400 more at $1,650. I purchased my ticket in mid-March 2017 for my June trip.  I felt $200 extra each way to sit in Premium Economy was worth it.

I spent a few days in Paris, onwards to Berlin via Air France, and from Berlin I flew to Athens (via Aegean Airlines) and then flew to Crete for approximately two weeks. While I knew my experience in Premium Economy would not be the same I experienced on Singapore Airlines this past December, I was quite pleased with Air France and what they offered.

This is a TravelSkills Reader Report by Jason Vaudrey, a frequent contributor to TravelSkills. Thanks, Jason! Would you like to submit your own Reader Report? We’d love to hear from you. Check out our guidelines.

My primary reason for choosing Premium Economy is the comfort of the seat and seat pitch. The other perks such as dedicated priority check-in lane, lounge access [for a fee – further explanation below], and alternative meal service options were just icing on the cake. I took Air France’s flight 83, an A380, that departs SFO in the mid-afternoon and arrives in Paris the following midmorning. The flight time was approximately 9 hours 30 minutes. (On the return, I flew an Air France B777.)

Arriving at SFO, Air France has a dedicated lane for Sky Priority, which includes Premium Economy, Business Class, and elite level SkyTeam members. Premium Economy passengers are allowed to bring two bags (a small backpack, handbag or laptop case and a wheelie bag) for a combined weight of 40 pounds. The combined weight limit for economy class passengers is 27 pounds. While Air France does charge to check luggage within Europe, you may check two bags for free on transatlantic flights. I brought a wheelie bag that met the size dimension restrictions for Air France and a backpack. Even with my laptop and my wheelie bag full, my weight was slightly more than 40 pounds, but the ticketing agent said, “that’s close enough” and allowed me to bring both bags on board the aircraft.

At SFO, KLM, Delta, and Air France share a lounge space and for $35, they allow Premium Economy passengers access. I did not have much time upon checking in and the time the flight boarded, so I did not use the lounge.

However,  when I returned I had many hours in Charles DeGaulle, I was able to access the Air France/Sky Priority lounge in terminal 2E for no fee. The agents scanned my boarding pass and welcomed me in and did not ask for me to pay. Nice! [NOTE: Despite Jason’s luck at getting in the lounge for free while flying premium economy, the Air France website shows that he should have been charged.]

The food and free beverages (including alcohol), the seating, the peace and quiet, plus views of the runways and fast, free Wi-Fi made my connection between my flight from Athens to CDG and my departure to SFO very enjoyable. Here are some photos from that visit:

Okay… back to boarding at SFO: Sky Priority members also get a dedicated security screening lane (both at SFO and CDG) which allowed me to skip the large queue for all the international passengers. Good news because at the time I cleared security, the queue was quite long. The shorter security line saved me approximately 30 minutes at the security checkpoint at SFO.

Premium Economy boards with Business Class passengers in Zone 1, and on the A380, the Premium Economy cabin is located on the upper deck. There are four rows in Premium Economy with bulkheads and curtains sectioning off the intimate cabin space. Seats are configured 2-3-2. I was seated in an aisle, 84K. (The layout in regular economy is 2-4-2 in the upper deck of the A380– on the main deck its 3-4-3.) On the B777, premium economy is configured 2-4-2.

The cabin on the SFO-CDG leg was full, except I had the good fortune of having the one empty seat in the cabin by me. With families occupying the middle section, there was not a single person in the middle section who wanted to take advantage of having a window seat and break up their party. On the A380 (but not on the B777), there are compartment bins next to window seats located under the windows, that allow you to store a purse, laptop bag or small backpack leaving you room underneath the seat in front of you.

The seat reclines downwards and out with a leg rest that also swings out. The seat is a fixed-back shell, and your space is never intruded on by the passenger in front of you nor are you intruding into the passenger behind you. I have read mixed reviews about the fixed-back shell (which I experienced on Cathay Pacific in their Economy section on their B747 in 2011), but I found it very comfortable. The premium economy seat pitch in the cabin is a generous 38”.

There is a metal bar that serves as a foot rest that comes down, but there is no midpoint stopping mechanism that allows you to set it to the height you would like. It is either all the way up and stored, or completely down to rest your feet. Because my legs are short, my legs could not reach the foot rest. But they did have the lower portion of the seat that extended and raised providing a nice rest for your legs. I just kept the foot bar stored.

There is also a small reading light that is right next to your shoulder that is not so bright and intrusive as the overhead lights on the panel above you. Passengers also are given noise cancelling headphones.

After we pushed back from the gate, I decided to occupy the window and take some photos of our takeoff and the beautiful views of flying over San Francisco before heading northeast to Paris.

Inflight entertainment is available and in premium economy, the screen is larger than the one in the economy cabin. There are a variety of movies, television programs, and an in-flight map with cameras for outside views, but France’s media system felt inferior compared with Cathay Pacific, Emirates or Singapore Airlines.

After takeoff, the cabin crew passed around amenity kits and a Premium Economy menu. Meal menus come with two options: chicken in an olive tomato Catalan sauce or a Conchiglie pasta in Marinara sauce with tomatoes and olives. I chose the chicken dish.

Prior to dinner, the cabin crew came around with a beverage cart offering drinks including champagne. Meals are served with plastic utensils there is no difference between the meals offered in economy versus premium economy. I was under the impression that we were being offered different meals than economy, but I observed the cabin crew, during meal service, offer the same meal options to the small Economy section that is located behind Premium Economy on the upper deck of the A380.

My dinner in SFO-CDG (above) was average in terms of taste and presentation. In addition to the plastic utensils, I was surprised to find a small plastic container of Mott’s applesauce included on the tray, along with an unappetizing, flavorless chocolate mousse. After dinner, they offered coffee, tea, and liqueurs, then dimmed the lights and I managed to sleep for four hours.

On the return from CDG to SFO, the fish with pasta was fantastic and the side items were tastier and had a better presentation. (See below)

In between meal service in both directions, light snacks included: mini sandwiches, fruit, and packaged cookies and crackers, which are set out in the galley for Economy and Premium Economy passengers to help themselves.

The cabin crew was very pleasant and helpful in responding to the call buttons. As with most overnight flights I have been on, whether they have been to Europe or Asia, I find the temperature of the cabin to be warmer than I would like and definitely a blanket is not required.

About two hours prior to landing in Paris, a warm breakfast was served. Again, the presentation and taste was lacking. The breakfast was not very appetizing and it included a dried-out frittata with two tater tots, a plastic dish of canned fruit and a cold blueberry muffin. See below

Upon landing at CDG, Sky Priority members are also given a special lane to clear immigration and customs and that also saved approximately 30 minutes.

In a nutshell: Despite my disappointment with the outbound flight’s meal options, I found the seat to be comfortable, the convenience of having a dedicated check-in lane for the flight, a special lane for security, clearing customs at CDG, and the surprise of being able to access the Sky Priority lounge at CDG (for free!), made Premium Economy worth it.

The cabin crews on both flights were amazing, friendly, and worked really hard to make sure everyone was comfortable and received what they were needing. I would definitely choose Air France again when flying to Europe.

This is a TravelSkills Reader Report by Jason Vaudrey, a frequent contributor to TravelSkills. Thanks, Jason! Would you like to submit your own Reader Report? We’d love to hear from you. Check out our guidelines.

ICYMI, see the 25 most recent TravelSkills posts right here

In the market for a new credit card? See our “Credit Card Deals” tab to shop around! It helps us help you!

Don’t miss out! Join the 185,000+ people who read TravelSkills every month! Sign up here for one email-per-day updates!